• Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • Ayn Gold & UK Open Markets

  • RSS The Consultant’s View – Articles & Audio Files

    • The Big Question! Limited Company, CIC or Registered Charity?
      Over the years I have helped set up and register a number of limited companies (both by shares and guarantee) and a number of registered charities and then on top of that countless voluntary... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social enterpri […]
    • Janet Braithwaite’s 10 Minute Interview with author Amal Abdalhakim-Douglas
      Janet Braithwaite’s 10 Minute Interview with Amal Abdalhakim-Douglas about his newly released book: Seven Secrets of Successful Fundraising Title: Seven Secrets of Successful Fundraising... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social enterprise o […]
    • Book Review by the Guardian’s Robert Ashton
      Reviewer: Robert Ashton – social entrepreneur and business author Book Title: Seven Secrets of Successful Fundraising – Amal Abdalhakim-Douglas ISBN: 978-0-9535993-4-9 Like most authors,... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social enterprise o […]
    • Banksta Rap
      My Name is Able GoldSteal The Original Banksta Rapper let me store all your gold for you (and give you back something certainly crapper) Bank charges and interest are not my greatest con’ even... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social enterp […]
    • Beyond Mary Portas – An Introduction to the Open Market
      Many months have passed sine the publication of the Mary Portas Revirew on the state of Britain’s High Street. Following on from that in recent days we have heard reports of the possible demise... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social enter […]
    • Calling The Twice Removed
      AVAILABLE NOW FROM THE PUBLISHERS: There is no reversal, no going back! That “second removal,” a mass migration from the Caribbean colonies of young men and women coming to help the ‘motherland’, to... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social […]
    • How to Raise £3,000 in 30 Days
      It will be obvious to many that £3,000 is not a lot of money for a big charity or major corporation. Conversely, for many very small organisations that may be  more than they raise in a whole year.... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social e […]
    • Let’s Not Leave any EU Money on the Table
       Do You Have a Mind To Access Some European Union Funding – Before It’s Too Late? If you and your organisation support young people in any way then you could be leaving accessible... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social enterprise or runn […]
    • How To Train Like an Olympic Athlete for Business & Personal Success: The Talent Development Model
      I am not a obsessive sports fanatic, but I certainly love playing and watching an array of sports. From the pure sports of athletics and boxing to the more contrived sports of Formula 1... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social enterprise or […]
    • Business Psychology Lessons from Formula 1 Racing
      In a recent post I stated that Formula 1 Racing was not a pure sport because of the heavy reliance on technology in terms of driver performance. However, despite that I still find it a fascinating... Short, sharp and straight forward advice for anyone wanting to satisfy their enterprising and entrepreneurial spirit, whether through self-employment, social en […]

Critique of a Charity’s Attempt to Collect Zakat

With the start of the new Islamic year upon us, I was reminded of a document that I had recently been given, and asked for my views concerning it. A document entitled: A Brief Guide to Zakat in the UK. It was produced by a Suffolk based charity in the UK. Of course from my own book written with Shaykh Abdalhaqq Bewley (Zakat – Raising a Fallen Pillar) and many subsequent writings and conversations, many will know that I don’t generally approve of charities taking on the collection of Zakat. In reality the pillar of Zakat requires a person in authority to be at the centre of it. If this person is backed up by a charity, then all well and good. For the moment we can overlook this as I want to concentrate on reviewing some of the other stances or methodologies that The Charity has adopted.

The Charity document has 6 pages. On page 1 they quite correctly state the great importance of sadaqa sent abroad to help needy Muslims and/or relatives. However, they quite rightly make a clear distinction between this and Zakat. Pleasingly they stress the fact that Zakat is to be collected and distributed locally and that sending it abroad is at best mukruh (disliked) except under very special circumstances. Indeed, on page 2 they offer evidence from the four madhabs to support this stance. This in itself is of utmost importance in that they have not fallen victim to the anti/non-madhabi stance that characterise the modernists, who have all but abandoned the deen.

The document continues on page 2 to outline some important characteristics needed for the collection and distribution of zakat, namely, ‘.. honest, reliable and competent..” So far so good, but unfortunately these words are followed by the word “organisations.” So here they have missed a trick. The deen was not established by organisations. The collection and distribution of Zakat is authorised by people in authority, amirs, governors, sultans and the like.

Committees and Boards of Trustees cannot do it. Look at those things a Muslim leader is entrusted with such as announcing the two eids (thus the beginning and end of Ramadan), minting the gold dinar and silver dirham, appointing Imams to lead the prayer, maintaining the weights & measures in the marketplace and of course the collection and distribution of Zakat. These thing are the responsibility of the man in charge and backed up by advisors, deputies or lieutenants and so on. He can even be supported by charitable institutions/awaqf like The Charity in question.

To their credit the author(s) get back on track on page 3 when clarifying who should pay Zakat and quite clearly address the issue of minors. The document also clarifies when Zakat is due (anytime really) and that it is not connected to Ramadan and thus not to be confused with Zakat-al-Fitr which is an obligation connected to fasting in Ramadan. Also on page 4 they address the nisab on monetary wealth which is either 20 gold dinars or 200 silver dirhams. They equate this to 40 ounces of silver. However in reality this is in fact closer to 19 troy ounces of silver and nearly 3 troy ounces of gold. It is perhaps easy to see why this mistake may have been made.

Firstly, not many people do the necessary research to establish what a dinar or dirham actually is. Today in many countries around the world Islamic Gold Dinars and Islamic Silver Dirhams are being minted under the auspices of the World Islamic Mint (WIM) according to the standards established by Umar ibn Al-Khattab. This includes the correlation specified between the Dinar and Dirham (that 7 dinars is the weight of 10 dirhams). hence we have a weight of 4.25 grams for a Gold Dinar and 2.975 grams for a Silver Dirham. So in weight the nisab would be 85 grams of gold or 595 grams of silver. Of course one should also work out the cost of obtaining a Silver Dirham or Gold Dinar in your locality and work it out on that price. In the UK the best place to look is on the Ayn Gold website.

It is interesting that they (The Charity) have decided to stick to the nisab of silver. This means that more people will be eligible to pay zakat as opposed to if the nisab of gold was taken. So at the time of writing anyone holding savings of around £1,000 (for over a year) would have to pay as opposed to well over £3,000 if the gold nisab were used. In my own community some years ago we made the decision to use the gold nisab. It was reasoned that this would avoid less well-off people having to pay, due to the depressed price of silver. However, I think that here The Charity have a much more authentic position by opting for silver in this matter. They do though, need to be aware of the current availability of actual silver dirhams in the UK and even the movement to have them used as currency. All of this is perhaps an indication that affairs of muamalat that involve daily commerce and other transactions tend not to be given the importance they are due. This is further evidenced by the fact that the document does not address the issue of Zakat on business stock or investments.

The Charity document quite correcly quotes from Surah Tawba the categories of person who may receive Zakat “These categories are the poor, the needy, workers in zakat, people whose hearts are to be reconciled (mu’allafat quloobuhum), captives, debtors, in the cause of Allah and wayfarers (travellers).”

Although not made clear it seems that The Charity are well aware that Zakat cannot be used to build mosques, schools or clinics and other similar noble causes.They are clear that it must be given to individuals in one of the eight categories mentioned. They are also well aware of the need to distribute Zakat locally. These two things by themselves are a great improvement and step forward that we hope will be replicated by other Muslim led charities. So for this the people involved with This Charity deserve great credit.

Sadly what has not been addressed is the matter of Muslim leadership, without which the pillar of Zakat can never truly be implemented properly. They have also failed to address the requirement to pay Zakat on monetary wealth in, Ayn or tangible wealth. In this case gold or silver (preferably dinars or dirhams) They are of course on shaky ground in assuming that paying in bank issued paper money is acceptable, but perhaps we will see something more on these matters at a later date.

May Allah grant us all Success establishing Zakat, abandoning riba, and being a part of bringing Allah’s Deen to life in the lands where we find ourselves.

Amin.

One Response

  1. Nice sharing , I like this article so much

    I request to all my brother and sisters Who see this message
    “plz visit this site —–>Town Medical Services and donate him

    thanks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: